the Medical referral in Maharatna PSU

Posted on December 8, 2011. Comments(2)     Status: Resolved Non-RTI's
Public Information Officer Steel Authority of India Limited SCOPE Minar, North Tower, 16th Floor, Laxmi Nagar District Centre, New Delhi -110092 Email: pio@sailex.com
  1. What are the facilities available in Plant Hospitals?
  2. Whether these hospitals are at par with the referral hospitals?
  3. If the plant hospitals are at par with referral hospitals? Whether the units including the corporate office, CMO, theRanchibased units, the metro offices which do not have hospital have referred to these plant unit hospitals?
  4. How much money spent on these hospitals?
  5. How many cases have been referred to outside hospitals and how much money given to these hospitals? Since 2001 onwards.
  6. Who are the dependents?
  7. Whether the referral candidate is solely dependent on the employee? Furnish names such employees and names of their dependent and the relation?
  8. Whether the referral is the Employee? Furnish their names?
  9. Furnish unit wise details  of employees for outside referral since 2001.

2 Responses to the Medical referral in Maharatna PSU

  1. RK - RTI Anonymous Team Member says:
    December 9, 2011 at 8:39 PM

    To RTI Team members -

    I find a number of RTI requests are being posted here in this page relating to SAIL, which is a major Public Sector Undertaking. In almost all these requests, very huge information are being sought.Added to this, most of the questions are either irrelevant or cannot be answerred. For example, in the present case,question like
    – whether the Hospitals are par with referral Hospitals?
    – How much money has been spent on these Hospitals?
    – How much money is given to these Hospitals?
    – What are the Dependents?
    These are only illustrative but not exclusive. I do not know whether these requests are coming from one person or from different persons. Even in some of the earlier requests I had commented that since the volume of information sought is very huge, the PIO can reject the request under Sction 7(9) of the RTI Act.

    • Anand - RTI Anonymous Team Member says:
      December 9, 2011 at 11:02 PM

      I agree with Mr. RK
      There is no point in asking so much information, that will anyway be rejected …

      The way, RTI-Anonymous is an organization works, is “REAL” people file for RTI from different parts of the country, except they are from a different state. The idea is to safeguard the original requestor.

      In cases like yours, it makes more sense to do a personal inspection of the documents … RTI-Anonymous cannot help you in this aspect, since it would not be feasible to do so

Leave a Reply